13 Most Hated Songs from the ’70s That Everyone Secretly Loves

The 1970s was a decade filled with a vibrant mix of music, from disco to rock. Yet, some songs, despite being widely criticized, have secretly found a place in many hearts.

Whether it’s the catchy melodies, unforgettable lyrics, or pure nostalgia, these tracks continue to spark debates while quietly remaining fan favorites.

Here are 13 songs that people love to pretend they hate but can’t resist singing along to.

1. “Muskrat Love” by Captain & Tennille

Kicking off the list is “Muskrat Love,” a quirky tune about two muskrats in love. This offbeat concept made some listeners cringe, but its charm is undeniable.

The duo’s harmonious voices and whimsical melody give the song an oddly hypnotic quality. Despite the unusual theme, many secretly enjoy its lighthearted romance and find themselves humming it long after it’s over.

2. “Disco Duck” by Rick Dees

Next up is “Disco Duck,” a novelty track that stormed the dance floors in the disco era. With its catchy beat and playful duck quacks, it became a massive hit despite its silliness.

Critics dismissed it as a gimmick, but its humor and high-energy rhythm make it impossible to ignore. People laughed at it then and still do now, but many secretly love its goofy charm.

3. “Afternoon Delight” by Starland Vocal Band

Few songs are as simultaneously adored and ridiculed as “Afternoon Delight.” Its sweet harmonies and suggestive lyrics have made it a topic of debate for decades.

Some listeners roll their eyes at its cheesiness, but its dreamy quality and lighthearted feel make it a guilty pleasure. Whether you admit it or not, this song has an undeniable feel-good vibe.

4. “Seasons in the Sun” by Terry Jacks

Often labeled as overly sentimental and melancholy, “Seasons in the Sun” is a song that divides listeners. Its reflective lyrics about life and loss make it deeply emotional for some and overly dramatic for others.

Despite the criticism, many secretly appreciate its nostalgic pull. It may not be the most uplifting song, but it tugs at the heartstrings in a way that few others do.

5. “Billy Don’t Be a Hero” by Paper Lace

With a storytelling style that paints a vivid picture of wartime sacrifice, “Billy Don’t Be a Hero” captured listeners’ attention despite its critics.

Some dismiss it as melodramatic, but the song’s message of heroism and loss still resonates with many. Its narrative-driven lyrics make it hard to forget, and for that reason, it holds a special place in many hearts.

6. “You Light Up My Life” by Debby Boone

This song remains a classic for romantic occasions, though some consider it overly sentimental. “You Light Up My Life” is filled with soaring vocals and heartfelt lyrics that have made it timeless.

Even those who find it a bit too emotional cannot deny its warmth and sincerity. It is the kind of song people secretly enjoy, especially in sentimental moments.

7. “The Night Chicago Died” by Paper Lace

This dramatic ballad is filled with action-packed storytelling and a larger-than-life atmosphere. While some criticize its historical inaccuracies, its energy and theatrical quality make it hard to ignore.

Listeners get caught up in its vivid narrative, and even those who claim to dislike it can’t help but sing along.

8. “Escape (The Pina Colada Song)” by Rupert Holmes

One of the most famous guilty pleasure songs, “Escape (The Piña Colada Song)” tells a cheeky story about a couple unknowingly answering each other’s personal ads.

Its catchy melody and playful lyrics make it an irresistible listen. While some might cringe at its cheesy charm, the song never fails to put a smile on people’s faces.

9. “Feelings” by Morris Albert

This ballad is infamous for being overly dramatic, but at the same time, its sincerity resonates with many listeners.

Despite being parodied over the years, its simple yet heartfelt lyrics about lost love have made it a lasting guilty pleasure. Even those who mock it cannot ignore the raw emotion in its melody.

10. “Convoy” by C.W. McCall

A song that captures the 1970s trucking culture, “Convoy” was a hit despite being labeled as a novelty track.

Its rebellious storyline and radio chatter-style verses give it a unique appeal. Even those who roll their eyes at it can’t resist its adventurous spirit.

11. “Kung Fu Fighting” by Carl Douglas

Few songs are as instantly recognizable as “Kung Fu Fighting.” Its martial arts theme and playful energy have made it a dance floor staple.

Critics may call it a novelty hit, but its infectious beat and lively rhythm have cemented its place in music history. Even if people pretend to dislike it, they still find themselves tapping along.

12. “Y.M.C.A.” by Village People

“Y.M.C.A.” by Village People is a song synonymous with fun. Its catchy melody and iconic dance moves make it a favorite at parties, even if some dismiss it as kitsch.

The song’s uplifting spirit and communal feel invite everyone to join in. It’s a track that brings people together, secretly cherished for its joyful energy.

13. “Copacabana (At the Copa)” by Barry Manilow

Finally, Barry Manilow’s “Copacabana (At the Copa)” is a song with a story that takes listeners to a lively nightclub. Some might call it melodramatic, but its narrative flair captures the imagination.

The song’s vivid imagery and catchy tune make it a favorite, even if some won’t admit it. It’s a theatrical experience in musical form, secretly enjoyed by many.